A kind of On September 20 this yr, on the event of the reception to commemorate Chalkis on the Elysee Palace, the President of the Republic requested for forgiveness “Devoted to the deserted combatants, to their households who suffered from focus camps, prisons, and denials.”
lastly! , Some individuals may say. Nevertheless, on nearer inspection, there’s nothing to have a good time. If this speech completes the institutional recognition of the “Tragedy of the Halks”, it isn’t worthy of respect for them. The presidential speech is neither a simply act nor the reality, however only a gesture of reminiscence. It’s questionable as a result of it’s primarily based on an instrumental interpretation of complementary phenomena, and extra broadly, an instrumental interpretation of the colonial state of affairs. It should by no means be named.
As a result of resonance of the three myths—loyalty, navy custom, and nationality—a historic narrative unfolds, underneath the guise of asking Hakis for forgiveness, forgiving France’s (post-)colonial crimes. On this story, Harkis is known as once more as an additional, and they need to help the story imposed on them. When it appears to mean to specific their long-awaited apology, how can they actually qualify to criticize such storage units? Is it actually attainable to heal the wound whereas misunderstanding the reason for the wound?
Within the first motion, President Macron linked the popularity of household abandonment and abuse with the celebration of loyalty.Doing so is way from defending the Republic’s “Highway to Fact”, As an alternative, it participated in its funeral, as a result of the expertise of recruiting harkis has little to do with any adherence to the flag, however with a sequence of social and historic circumstances.
Normally, these stem from the connection between two principal components: on the one hand, native allegiance and stability, however, the ambiance of violence and suspicion established by two rival camps (French Military and Nationwide Liberation Military, ALN) . However, in colonial conditions the place indigenous populations are exploited and impoverished. Harkis didn’t combat for France, however for France, and is now extensively documented in his work within the humanities and social sciences, and Emmanuel Macron himself additionally raised this level. However, as within the reverse syllogism, the actual fact of contributing to France turns into an expression of false patriotism and de facto loyalty, which frees itself from the burden of selection.